TY - BOOK AU - Hobhouse,L.T.(Leonard Trelawney) TI - The Elements of Social Justice / PY - 1965/// CY - London : PB - Ruskin House , KW - Social ethics KW - Social problems KW - 11 N1 - CONTENTS CHAPTER I. ETHICS AND SOCIAL PHILOSOPHY.. 1. Institutions are not ends but means. Politics are sub- ordinate to Ethics. 2. This was clearly recognised by the Utilitarians in insisting on the impartial application of the "Greatest Happiness principle." 3. They erred in identi- fying happiness with pleasure and in the analysis of motive. 4. The good as a harmony of Experience with Feeling. 5. Harmony as opposed both to anarchy and repression. 6. Harmony of attainment as the object of rational endeavour. CHAPTER II. RIGHTS AND DUTIES. 1. On the principle of Harmony the Common Good cannot be opposed to the good of individuals, 2. nor the rights of individuals set up against the Common Good as the doctrine of Natural Rights implied. 3. A right imposes duties and s one term of a moral relation. 4. It is not a condition precedent to social welfare but an element in social welfare. 5. Prima facic conflict of rights. The test of operative consistency and the method of synthesis. 6. Illustrated by the case of Nationality. CHAPTER III. LIBERTY-(1) MORAL FREEDOM. 1. Freedom as self-determination in the absence of external constraint has an application beyond the life of man. 2. Internally the life of a man is free as far as it is har- monious. 3. Freedom of the will in the sense of indeter- mination is not ethically tenable. 4. But implies deter- mination by the outcome of action, 5. and is not affected by the superficial externality of interests. IO THE ELEMENTS OF SOCIAL JUSTICE PAGE CHAPTER IV. LIBERTY (continued).-(2) SOCIAL AND POLI- 57 TICAL FREEDOM 1. Freedom within a community involves restraints, 2. in the form of a system of rights each of which is "a liberty." 3. But what is the relation between "liberties" and liberty? 4. Liberty rests on the spiritual character of personal and social development, 5. and the protection of rights ("liberties") on the incompatibility in practice of opposed lines of conduct. In general no restraint is justified where no right is invaded. 6. The extension and more complete definition of rights implies a better system of "liberties." 7. This holds even of the extension of public rights so far as the State acts honestly and intelligently. 8. For Liberty is the ground of Rights as such and as the central condition of development is a leading consideration in the definition of any given right. 9. Tutelage of the immature and infirm mind is a duty, which must not be so interpreted as to impair the general principle of self-regulation. 10. "Political liberty" is no adequate guarantee of personal freedom, but tends to secure government by the will prevalent in a com- munity and thus to substitute the appeal to the will for force. 11. Liberty in general as the replacement of Force by Will is both the effect and cause of social harmony. 12. The historic development of Liberty and its present danger. CHAPTER V. JUSTICE AND EQUALITY. 94 1. Equality, as an arguable principle of social organization, means absolute equality in some fundamental rights, or 2. equal proportion of rights to desert, or 3. to needs. 4. These principles agree in founding the rights of the indi- vidual on personality. 5. The equality of law consists in the universality of some fundamental rules and the impartial application of all rules. 6. Justice involves an equal claim on the common good in respect of equal needs, 7. subject to the adequate maintenance of necessary functions. 8. Neither the development of one class at the expense of another, nor of the community at the expense of the individual can be justified by the principle of Harmony. 9. The historical conflict between equality and inequality. 10. Approxi- mations to equality under physical limitations. CONTENTS CHAPTER VI. PERSONAL JUSTICE. 1. Responsibility as the natural discipline of the will 2. en- forced by Retributive Justice which is founded on the harmonization of personal and common interests. 3. This does not admit of the infliction of any evil for its own sake. 4. Subdivisions of the treatment of justice. CHAPTER VII. THE PAYMENT OF SERVICE.. 1. Exchange at equal market values is just only if values are determined on just principles. 2. These involve the direction of the general economy to the provision of needs in proportion to their urgency, 3. the non-existence of function- less wealth, 4. the remuneration of all work required by the industrial system on terms adequate to maintain the worker's civic efficiency, 5. and additional remuneration in proportion to increased vital costs. 6. As long as the interest of the individual or the community are not fully harmonized by other methods remuneration should also increase in ac- cordance with the social value of his work, 7. in such wise that every field of work is on the whole equally attractive to ability. 8. On this basis an economy resting on free exchange is ethically desirable. CHAPTER VIII. PROPERTY AND ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION. 1. Property as the exclusive right of control. 2. The attri- butes of property as such to be distinguished from those peculiar to private property. 3. Property as the basis of freedom 4. and of power. 5. The assignment of property should be so conceived as to secure freedom for the individual and power for the community. CHAPTER IX. SOCIAL AND PERSONAL FACTORS IN WEALTH. 1. The claims of the community on wealth may be based on the performance of function, 2. or on the absence of just claims on the part of any member. The position of inherited wealth. 3. Social and unsocial wealth. 4. Social and un- social methods of gain. 5. Resulting partition of owner- ER -