An Essay On The Foundations Of Geometry /
= مقال عن أساسيات الهندسة
By Bertrand A. W. Russell With A New Foreword By Morris Kline Professor Of Mathematics At New York University
- New York : Dover Publications, Inc. , 1956
- 201 Page : illustration ; 24 Cm
Dedication : Το John Mctaggart Ellis Mctaggart To Whose Discourse And Friendship Is Owing The Existence Of This Book
Contents :INTRODUCTION - OUR PROBLEM DEFINED BY ITS RELATIONS TO LOGIC, PSYCHOLOGY AND MATHEMATICS - 1. The problem first received a modern form through Kant, who connected the à priori with the subjective - 2. A mental state is subjective, for Paychology, when its immediate cause does not lie in the outer world - 3. A piece of knowledge is à priori, for Epistemology, when without it knowledge would be impossible - 4. The subjective and the à priori belong respectively to Psychology and to Epistemology. The latter alone will be investigated in this essay - 5. My test of the à priori will be purely logical: what knowledge is necessary for experience? - 6. But since the necessary is hypothetical, we must include, in the à priori, the ground of necessity - 7. This may be the essential postulate of our science, or the elemont, in the subject-matter, which is necessary to experience - 8. Which, however, are both at bottom the same ground - 9. Forecast of the work - CHAPTER I. A SHORT HISTORY OF METAGEOMETRY. - 10. Metageometry began by rejecting the axiom of parallels - 11. Its history may be divided into three periods: the synthetic, the metrical and the projective - 12. The first period was inaugurated by Gauss, - 194. What are we to do with the contradictions in space? - 195. Three contradictions will be discussed in what follows - 196. (1) The antinomy of the Point proves the relativity of space, - 197. And shows that Geometry must have some reference to matter, - 198 By which means it is made to refer to spatial order, not to empty space. - 199. The causal properties of matter are irrelevant to Geometry, which must regard it as composed of unextended atoms, by which points are replaced - 200. (2) The circle in defining straight lines and planes is overcome by the same reference to matter - 201. (3) The antinomy that space is relational and yet more than relational, - 202. Seems to depend on the confusion of empty space with spatial order - 203. Kant regarded empty space as the subject-matter of Geometry, - 204. But the arguments of the Aesthetic are inconclusive on this point, - 205. And are upset by the mathematical antinomies, which prove that spatial order should be the subject-matter of Geometry. - 206. The apparent thinghood of space is a psychological illusion, due to the fact that spatial relations are immediately given. - 207. The apparent divisibility of spatial relations is either ant illusion, arising out of empty space, or the expression of the possibility of quantitatively different spatial relations - 208. Externality is not a relation, but an aspect of relations. Spatial order, owing to its reference to matter, is a real relation - 209. Conclusion
This classic of science is a mathematical and physical analysis of the place of the a priori in geometric knowledge. It attempts to answer basic questions in the area where philosophy and higher mathematics meet. "What geometrical knowledge must be the logical starting point for a science of space?" "What geometry must be logically necessary for the experience of any form of space outside our minds?" "What are the properties of this space, and how are objects in it interrelated?" While Russell's solution to these questions is not the generally accepted modern solution, it is still most interesting as an exceptionally clear statement of a most important scientific problem, and as a logically coherent system devised by one of the great minds of our time. It is also a rich mine of insights, expressed with all Russell's usual clarity, precision, and elegantly reasoned analysis. This study is especially valuable for its coverage of the contributions of such continental thinkers as Kant, Lotze, Vaihinger, Herbart. Helmholtz, Erdmann, and Riemann. Besides reviewing and highlighting essential features of 19th century non-Euclidean geometry. it contains analyses and critiques not obtainable from purely technical books. "His insights, as well as his review of 19th century work in non- Euclidean geometry, remain valuable," Scientific Monthly.