Ideas of History . Volume Two , The Critical Philosophy of History /
The Critical Philosophy of History
= أفكار التاريخ
Edited by Ronald H. Nash
- First Edition
- New York : Dutton, 1969
- 90 Pages ; 21 cm
Preface: What Is History? xiii - 1. ST. AUGUSTINE 3 - Introduction 3 - Augustine: The City of God 7 - Bibliography - 23 - 2. Giambattista Vico 25 - Introduction 25 - Vico: The New Science 30 - Bibliography - A. 1. Melden: Historical Objectivity, a "Noble Dream"? - Ernest Nagel: An Evaluation of Historical Relativism - William Dray: The Historian's Problem of Selection - Bibliography - THE PROBLEM OF HISTORICAL CAUSATION - Introduction - W. H. Walsh: Historical Causation - Raymond Aron: Evidence and Inference in History 2 - Raphael Demos: The Language of History - Bibliography - HISTORICAL DETERMINISM - Introduction - Sidney Hook: The Hero in History - Isaiah Berlin: Historical Inevitability - Ernest Nagel: Determinism in History - Bibliography - 5. CONCLUSION - Georges Florovsky: The Study of the Past
There are two divisions of the philosophy of history -speculative and critical. Critical philosophy of his-tory attempts to clarify the nature of the historian's own inquiry. It criticizes the fundamental beliefs of the historian and analyzes the basic concepts he uses. This approach to the science of history asks such questions as: How does the historien come to under-stand the past? Is the historian's method of inquiry significantly different from the kind of inquiry found in the natural sciences? Can the historian be objective? Many contemporary philosophers, are convinced that questions like these are the only legitimate problems left for the philosopher of history and that all at-tempts at formulating speculative theories about history must be abandoned. Volume Two of this two-volume anthology-the finest survey of the subject to be published in recent years -contains selections from most of the important criti-cal philosophers, including the following: Auguste Comte, John Stuart Mill, Wilhelm Dilthey, R. G. Col-lingwood, W. H. Walsh, Carl G. Hempel, Wiliam Dray, Maurice Mandelbaum, Rudolph H. Weingart-ner, Charles A. Beard, Carl L. Becker, A. I. Melden, Ernest Nagel, Raymon Aron, Raphael Demos, Sidney Hook, Isaiah Berlin, and Georges Florovsky